publius has an interest post on the politics of Ricci. My (quite amateurish) takeaway from the commentaries I've been reading is threefold:
a) The circuit ruling that Sonia Sotomayor decided applied the correct precedent, notwithstanding how unfair the reverse discrimination seemed to many of us.
b) The Supreme Court overturned this with a new rule, which is their prerogative. This does not reflect on the appropriateness of the circuit decision, which was correct given the precedents. But the new rule is a welcome development for those of who want to live in a more colorblind world.
c) After devising this rule, publius argues, the court made a procedurally innappropriate summary judgement, not sending the case back to trial for more fact finding, which he deems "pure politics".
Trump picks former Florida Rep. Weldon to lead CDC
-
Weldon is a doctor of more than 40 years and an Army veteran.
3 hours ago
No comments:
Post a Comment