JOHN BOLTON is probably the only person curmudgeonly enough to frown on the release of Laura Ling and Euna Lee. Mr Bolton is no fool in general, but in calling this a "classic case of rewarding bad behaviour", his analysis is just plain wrong. It depends on a mistaken, and dangerous, assumption made again and again during the Bush administration, and these days still by Republicans out of power. This is the idea that negotiations themselves are some kind of reward for bad regimes, and until they lay down their arms and promise America everything it wants, they should be utterly shunned.Bolton is hardly the only one, though. Krauthammer: "It was a hostage ransom. No question at all," He says he doesn't know if money or goods were promised or exchanged.
According to my simple quick think through history, George W. Bush may be the only postwar president never to have met with an adversarial leader (unless perhaps you count Vladimir Putin, which I wouldn't). This is no Democratic weakness, appeasing baddies. Presidents Eisenhower, Nixon, Reagan and the first George Bush all made major diplomatic breakthroughs by dealing with unfriendly states, because they weren't afraid that a photo-op was a concession. Mr Bolton remains terrified that it is, even though neither Bill Clinton nor Barack Obama have conceded anything (publicly) more than a few photographs for the release of two young women.
If America had a shadow foreign secretary as Britain has, Mr Bolton would probably be it. He is ceaselessly sought out for the conservative view on the foreign policy of the day. It's a shame. The right needs to get past bluster as policy—or at least stop fetishising Ronald Reagan.
Wednesday, August 5
Why the Right's foreign policy sucks
I'll let DIA explain:
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2009
(1987)
-
▼
August
(138)
- If we could at least agree on one thing...
- NYC decrees coffee and tobacco do not mix
- Democrats and statism
- Who decides what care is worth the cost?
- "An interview with Barney Frank"
- Perverse Lead Regulation
- Chart of the day
- FTC prohibits commercial robocalls
- America's smallest bank
- One for the nerds
- General McChrystal gets his hippie on
- Public stuff
- Hathos alert
- Kennedy's deregulatory legacy
- The first congressional website
- And the beat goes on and on
- No crying was performed during the writing of this...
- Fascism and Freedom
- Quote of the Day
- Brace for the Kennedy Memorial Health Bill
- More flawed and more influential than his brothers
- Radley and Yglesias
- Medicare as political football
- CDC promotes involuntary male genital mutilation
- Infidel employment opportunity?
- Questions about health reform
- Why do Americans like Europe?
- Big brother, big expense hole
- There goes the filibuster
- This appeals to my inner hobo
- Yeesh
- Violence: a historical perspective
- Economic purgatory
- There really are sixteen.
- Quote of the day
- Knowing your opponent
- Photo of the week
- Illegal health reform
- The crime of retail
- A trillion here, a trillion there...
- Why I oppose government programs
- Quote of the day
- Political utility of terror threats
- Heads up
- Crime rates
- Rand Paul's money bomb
- Charlie always was an opportunist
- 2girls1bike
- Government does great stuff
- Japanese pig rodeo
- Tribute to the First Amendment
- Medicare's insolvency
- Science proves zombies could annihilate humans
- Why McCain lost
- Moderate is the new liberal, or we're all socialis...
- GOP hopeful Mike Huckabee
- DNA evidence can be fabricated, scientists show
- Evolution of the public option
- Prohibitions
- Congress deadlocked over how to not provide health...
- Refreshment contraband
- Quote of the day
- Obama's behavioral economics working a bit too well
- Government Spending vs. Economic Growth
- Stat of the day
- Telling Grandma 'No'
- "Put down the hammer"
- Obama's health-care plan won't make time stand still
- Slippery slope
- Extreme social conservatism
- Quote of the day
- Level playing field, hah
- Tax propaganda
- Crazy Islamism watch
- Public option ignorance
- Your name is Icarus, ctd.
- Dead heat
- Your papers, please
- "How American Health Care Killed My Father"
- I am sooo doped right now......
- "Why I Interrupted Bill Clinton’s Speech at Netroo...
- Reality check
- Carbon taxes and market distortions
- How Dems lost control of the debate
- Why we desperately need to cut spending after the ...
- Straight talk on health-care
- Hawking wares inside the bubble
- BSG reremake
- This elephant doesn't forget
- What Social Security teaches us about health-care
- Public health-care and loss of innovation
- Bill to legalize online poker introduced in the Se...
- Advocacy group decries PETA's inhumane treatment o...
- Obama, lobbyists, take active roles in talks on he...
- Where is this?
- Recession declared over; expansion begins
- Riding the fox
- Finally, an issue I can get behind.
- At what cost, cutting off a leg?
- How to improve health-care without spending other ...
-
▼
August
(138)



No comments:
Post a Comment