Showing posts with label secularism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label secularism. Show all posts

Thursday, June 4

Secular countries are more peaceful



Methodology here. Conclusion:
..there are several possible reasons for this. It could be that people living in turbulent countries turn to religion, or it could be that religion is not a good way to structure modern society.

Whatever, it's another blow to the idea that secularization leads to social meltdown. Atheist countries are, in fact, more peaceful.

Friday, May 8

Open letter to the Republican party

Sensuous Curmudgeon writes to fellow Republicans:
As our party is going though a much-needed period of introspection, please consider that there was a time when this party stood for the Constitution, the rule of law, national defense, free enterprise, limited government, low taxes, balanced budgets, and individual rights. We still honor those principles; but those who now govern have no concern for or even understanding of such matters.

While the other party has been winning elections and undermining everything we have traditionally valued, what issues dominate our political discourse? Our party has been talking about sex and religion.

When we say “sex,” we mean topics like abstinence, promiscuity, homosexuality, pre-marital relations, contraception, sodomy, nudity, pornography, masturbation, same-sex marriage, sex education, abortion, and morning-after pills. Does that list sound familiar? It should, because those are the issues that too often dominate your campaigns.

Except for late-term abortion, where the other party has an extreme position that could be exploited (except that it’s lost in a sea of other sex-related issues), there is absolutely no reason to discuss such matters as part of our party’s policies. The Constitution doesn’t give the federal government any authority over those issues. If they need to be addressed, it should be done only at the state level.

When we speak of religion, we mostly mean the current movement to insert religious doctrines into public school science classes, especially creationism and its love-child, intelligent design. It seems to us that this is a latter-day substitute for prayer in public schools, which is essentially a dead issue these days, but still a hot-button item. There are other religious issues, like objections to certain areas of biological research.

Our obsession with creationism and blocking biological research has earned us the reputation of being an anti-science party, which is a burden our adversaries are delighted to exploit — notwithstanding their Luddite opposition to nuclear energy, oil exploration, aerospace technology, etc. Aside from that, religious issues should not concern the national government — especially when we have so many vital matters — our traditional principles — that must be addressed before the republic is lost forever.

[...]

An inordinate emphasis on sex and religion makes hypocrites of half of us, and fools of all. More importantly, it will permanently marginalize the party, while the opponents of our traditional principles triumph.
Wait, let's break down those 'traditional principles':
  1. the Constitution, the rule of law: Unchecked executive power, illegal torture and mistreatment of detainees, denial of due process? These are not traditional nor Reaganesque principles.
  2. national defense: In case you hadn't noticed, the Cold War is over. We already waste way more GDP on defense than any other nation. And Republicans remain intent on massively overreacting to terror threats.
  3. free enterprise: I think freer migration bears on free enterprise in the same way as free trade, so this could be better.  But yes, Republicans are good on trade.
  4. limited government: Wake me up when the party is ready to repeal No Child Left Behind, Medicare Part D, and the Patriot Act.
  5. low taxes: Sure, except they're not sustainable without cutting spending, something Republicans failed to do.
  6. balanced budgets: Only when out of power. Don't make me laugh.
  7. and individual rights: All the sex stuff discussed above is one massive failure here. But surely the War on Drugs is every bit as pernicious.
In conclusion:  sure man, the social conservative sex stuff is unquestionably bigoted, backwards-looking, and deeply embarrassing to secular center-righters.  But the party's got plenty of bigger problems, hence the Obamacon phenom.

The reason for Obamaconism is that today, on balance, Democrats are better than Republicans on their 'traditional principles'. Until the party realizes and reforms this, I hope you enjoy your time in the wilderness.

Monday, May 4

Quote of the day II

I would like to reassure the contributors to this unusual Web site. You don’t need to go through such acrobatics to oppose marriage equality. You can just be against gay marriage without any justification. You guys could find a comfortable place here in Europe. We have a lot of far right parties that are based on identity and tradition, and they reject gay marriage as a question of national honor. They want heterosexual superiority because their national group is supposed to be more macho than the other countries. That is good enough, really. Unfortunately you’re stuck in the US where pure ethnic and cultural arguments don’t work. Americans are just too fair-minded and so astoundingly dynamic.

&mdashDanilo at Secular Right, Gay marriage and unintended consequences

Saturday, April 4

Respect people, not beliefs

Bloc Raisonneur: "This video, part of the One Law For All campaign in the UK, cannot be shown and distributed enough."


I couldn't agree more. This idea that civil courts should judge Muslims, Christians, and others by the rules of their religion rather than uniform civil laws is patently absurd.

What has happened to secularism in Europe?

Thursday, March 26

Secularism works



Secular free choice works on this and a whole host of issues. For instance many Jehova Witness' kids have died in the past because their parent's religion was against blood transfusions. Tragic though it may seem, this outcome is consistent with a free society of personal & parental responsibility.

We know some people will always persist with tragically dumb beliefs. For instance the Pope stated that condoms make the AIDS problem in Africa worse, which flies in the face of all evidence.

But people making dumb choices and having the opportunity to independently take responsibility for and learn from their mistakes is a lot better than a government regimenting our choices for us. That is why the socially conservative politics of evangelical Christianists like Dr. James Dobson or the nanny statism of the Left are so misguided and harmful on balance.

Sunday, March 22

Blasphemy laws

Via Secular Right:
Mr. Kalman had already formed one such corporation for his information-technology business and now wanted the same status for his sideline as a filmmaker, the better to write off expenses on his income taxes.

The first line on the document asked Mr. Kalman to supply his chosen corporate name, and he printed it in: I Choose Hell Productions, LLC. In a personal bit of existentialism, Mr. Kalman believed that, even if life was often hellish, it was better than suicide.

A week later, the daily mail to Mr. Kalman’s home in the Philadelphia suburb of Downingtown brought a form letter from the Pennsylvania Department of State. His corporate filing had been rejected, the letter explained, because a business name “may not contain words that constitute blasphemy, profane cursing or swearing or that profane the Lord’s name.”

Mr. Kalman felt quite certain, he recalled here the other day, that the letter was some kind of prank. Nobody had even signed it. And though he did not know it at the time, Pennsylvania had granted corporate designation to entities like Devil Media, Vomit Noise Productions and Satanic Butt Slayers.

After a couple more readings, though, Mr. Kalman realized that the rejection was genuine. Pennsylvania, it turned out, indeed had a law against blasphemy…
Read the whole thing here.

Wednesday, February 25

Happy meal conservatism

John Derbyshire:
Much as their blind loyalty discredited the Right, perhaps the worst effect of Limbaugh et al. has been their draining away of political energy from what might have been a much more worthwhile project: the fostering of a middlebrow conservatism. There is nothing wrong with lowbrow conservatism. It’s energizing and fun. What’s wrong is the impression fixed in the minds of too many Americans that conservatism is always lowbrow, an impression our enemies gleefully reinforce when the opportunity arises….

It does so by routinely descending into the ad hominem—Feminazis instead of feminism—and catering to reflex rather than thought. Where once conservatism had been about individualism, talk radio now rallies the mob. “Revolt against the masses?” asked Jeffrey Hart. “Limbaugh is the masses.”

In place of the permanent things, we get Happy Meal conservatism: cheap, childish, familiar. Gone are the internal tensions, the thought-provoking paradoxes, the ideological uneasiness that marked the early Right.
E.D. Kain agrees

Monday, February 23

Sanity at NRO

Andrew Stuttaford writes at the Corner:
RE: Alan, there are many ways to describe what Secretary Geithner is up to (quite a few of them deservedly unflattering), but to label it as 'socialist scheming' is, with respect, a stretch. The only consistent theme I can detect on Geithner's part is a determination to keep some sort of show on some sort of road. Fair enough, I think. Somehow I suspect that seizing the commanding heights of the economy is not one of his aims. Lenin still sleeps.

As for the idea that government capital injections into the banks sit like "ill-disguised Trojan horses", I look at those ruins of banks and then I look at what they have taken down with them, and (to push the analogy further, probably, than it ought to go) find myself wondering who is Troy and who is the horse.

The fact is that nationalization of some of the banks may well be the least-bad next step to take. The key will be to ensure that they are kept as wards of the state for as brief a time as possible and that political interference in their day-to-day running is kept to an absolute minimum.
But Mr. Stuttaford also writes for Secular Right, so we already knew he was sane ; )

Friday, February 13

Evolution, schmevolution

Comedy Central insider gathered the best evolution-related Daily Show clips.

Heather Mac Donald has another well-written post on theology and belatedness: "looks to me like they ran out of ideas".

Explaining the hand of God

Heather Mac Donald wants answers:

Will Bill O’Reilly or anyone else who saw the hand of God in the safe landing of US Airways Flight 1549 this January please explain why God chose not to save Continental Connection Flight 3407, which plunged into a house outside of Buffalo last night, killing all 49 people on board and a resident on the ground?

Among the explanations which will not be accepted: “humans cannot possibly fathom God’s mysterious ways.” Oh yes they can, apparently—when something good happens. Having found proof of God’s love in the safe conclusion of US Airways Flight 1549, believers cannot now turn around and claim that God’s ways are veiled just because something disastrous happens. If it’s legitimate to infer beneficence from a happy outcome, it is equally plausible to infer malice or at least indifference from a negative outcome. You can’t pick and choose the actions in which you find God’s will transparent.

Oh yes you can! Here's how it works: Whenever something really good happens, it's because God loves us. And whenever something bad happens it's not because God willed it to happen -- he didn't! -- rather, it's because of sin. It's really that simple.

You may not have heard, but original sin -- both human and angelic kinds (see: the fall of Lucifer, and tree of knowledge in Eden) -- are to blame for all the evil in this world. God is not responsible, he just "allows it". Nevermind that because all have sinned (as well as -- gasp! -- fallen short of the glory of their Creator) that this means we're incapable of not sinning. That's what saviors are for! Jesus will save you, Heather. You just have to believe!. Tithing is optional but highly encouraged, and his priests have been hard at work bringing back indulgences for even more convenience!

So regarding the bad things, Heather, the correct inference is your need to be saved. You need someone to protect you from bad things, and only Jesus is in a vague enough position to do so while not actually taking responsibility for any bad things that happen to people who trust in him. Sometimes his mother Mary will help pick up some slack, but she's usually too busy listening to prayers. Yet since Jesus is definitionally perfect, he's still quite literally the best imaginary friend you'll ever have.

Now about Bill O'Reilly: it's really hard work finding good things to give God credit for in these tough times. So stop hassling the man! Just look at all the cognitive dissonance he already has to deal with:

Saturday, January 31

Which side is more hostile to science, the right or the left?

John Derbyshire:

Following my having said (previous post) that any political position will find some human-science results obnoxious, a reader asked me, off-line, to identify a finding — not a practice, like embryo-destructive stem cell research, but a finding — that is obnoxious to conservatives.

I think the leading candidate here is the work on child development showing that parenting styles don’t matter much, perhaps not at all above a certain very low level (locking the kids in the basement and feeding them cat food). The canonical statement was given by Judith Rich Harris in The Nurture Assumption:  “Group socialization theory makes this prediction: that children would develop into the same sort of adults if we left their lives outside the home unchanged — left them in their schools and their neighborhoods — but switched all the parents around.” That’s got to be painful for a family-values conservative to read, yet it seems to be the current consensus.

For the Left, pretty much anything to do with heritability of human characteristics, other than undeniable visible ones, is obnoxious because such things violate the “psychic unity of mankind” (in its modern reading, which seems to me not precisely congruent with Bastian’s). Most obnoxious of all to the Left is the idea that homo sap., like any other widely-distributed species, exhibits regional variations between its big, old, settled, mostly-inbred populations.

It’s an interesting question whether the Right or the Left is more science-hostile, net-net. I insist that ideologues on both sides are science-hostile; but which kind of politics is more of an obstacle to the advance of our understanding, is arguable. Since science is mostly carried out in places where Right Creationists, Geocentrists, etc.  have no influence, but blank-slate Left “culturists” and po-mo words-have-no-meaning deconstructionists have tremendous influence, I’d guess the Left has the potential to do more damage, at least in the human sciences. I’d defer to Mr. Hume on this, though, as he’s better acquainted with the situation on the ground, in actual labs and institutes.

Wednesday, January 28

Sorry but atheism makes no positive claims

Andrew puts up some email from atheists readers.

They get this interesting response:
Your atheist readers make the classic move of pretending to be the referee when in fact they are just another player on the field. They are treating it as an intellectual puzzle rather than what it actually is for every last of us: a lived commitment. This is why the term "Atheist" itself is so misleading. You're an atheist, fine. I'm an A-Vishnuist, and an A-Buddhist, and an A-Teapotist. Telling me what you don't believe tells me very little, but it's a really cool way to get into the conversation in such a way that everyone has to defend their positions except you -- you get to attack.

This would be valid were this merely an intellectual exercise. There you can usefully indulge the distinctly modern prejudice that doubt is more reasonable than belief. But you can no more avoid making a positive choice about the source of meaning in your life and the universe than you can avoid living in some country. You can talk about which country is best to live in, but the atheist pretends you can live in no country at all.

You gotta live somewhere, and you gotta believe in something, because your beliefs are being expressed every day in how you live your life. Atheists should be forced to articulate their positive position (say, secular humanism) as price of admission to the conversation. So when your reader wants to "put the burden of proof on the one making a specific, positive claim," I simply point out that living your life is a specific, positive claim, and thus everyone has to bear the burden of proof equally.
Analogies can be fun: what if I live on a boat in international water -- or would that be agnosticism?

But I don't see why we should have to bear a burden of proof if I'm not making a positive claim. I too am an A-Vishnuist, an A-Buddhist, an A-Teapotist, but also an a-theist. Living my life is not a "specific, positive claim" any more than a monkey or a dog living its life is a "specific, positive claim". We're all atheists unless we have a positive belief in something that qualifies as "theism". Some of us atheists might be "secular humanists", others not.

I am secular. But I am not a humanist, because I believe that future nonhuman sapient beings should be persons too. There is nothing about my philosophy of life that restricts itself to humanity, other than the fact that humans are currently the only known sentient beings.

Saturday, October 18

Secular religious freedom does not equal 'respect'

A great entry:
Much has been made in the media about 'respecting' a person's religion. This is especially occurring as of late in the United Kingdom where Muslim immigrants are demanding accommodation and respect for their religious beliefs, which are many times at conflict with existing law and regulation. Though, not to pick on Muslims, there have been cases involving nearly every religion conceived by man, where a belief system is expected by its followers to be held in esteem by all, follower or not.

A circumstance of birth, which many times dictates what particular religion one adheres to, is not a factor that demands respect. Nor is a 'choice' to follow centuries old mythology a means to earn respect. If a religion holds to certain tenets, it is not the obligation of all humans on the globe to treat these beliefs with reverence. Religious beliefs are a personal matter that do not require all to pay heed, only the believers, and trying to impose your beliefs on others only indicates a level of insecurity with knowing there are those who think differently than you. A secular society endorses no religion, or lack of religion, it is neutral in the area of faith leaving open the choice of beliefs to the individual... not the state.

Respect your own faith and show it reverence by keeping it a private matter, doing so will illustrate you are confident and secure in your beliefs without the insecure need to ask others to conform as well. If you follow a religious text that requires your government to adhere to certain tenets, it would follow that moving to a secular country where all are free to choose a personal creed is not going to provide the established theocratic rule required for your beliefs. A better option would be to seek out and reside in a country that would provide the rule of law that conforms to the scripture of your faith.

In a converse situation the theocracy will not bend for the immigrated secularist, nor should it. It is not the role of any government to capitulate to every new citizen by altering law and regulation to conform to individual creed.
As a matter of public policy, I of course respect everyone's right to believe as they wish.

This is the essence of secularism.

On a personal level I don't necessarily respect their beliefs, just their rights to have them, as long as they respect the rights of others.

When my religious friends speak to me of secularism as being bad, yet that they don't want a theocracy, it's incoherent. You can only have one or the other. There is by definition no middle ground.

"Positive secularism" is an oxymoron, as would be "negative secularism".

Secularism is an absence of judgment, not a judgment.

Now it is certainly possible for misguided, self-professed "secularists" to be against the free expression of religious beliefs. But to call this secularism is false.

Please correct their terminology instead of attacking true secularism, unless you're actually trying to advocate theocracy.