[I]f it seems as though torture ever yields important and actionable intelligence more quickly than alternative methods, we’re supposed to take it for granted that this completes the necessary utilitarian analysis. And this is just absurd. How does torture affect the willingness of enemy combatants to surrender? How much does it complicate our relations with allies? How many people does it help to radicalize against the United States? How many non-radicals does it leave sufficiently disgusted that they’re less motivated to assist the U.S. in fighting radicalism in their communities? You’ll notice that torture-fans never really attempt to deal remotely seriously with any of these questions; they just babble inanities about how Fanatics Will Hate Us No Matter What. Which, of course, some will—but that’s hardly to the point, is it?
Tuesday, January 5
Ignoring the cost of torture
Via the Dish, Julian Sanchez has been reading NRO's Corner and comments on the pro-torture right's stunning stupidity:
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2010
(454)
-
▼
January
(57)
- "Enough is Enough"
- Presidential Question Time with the House GOP
- Scott Brown in his own words
- Californians to vote on expansive green immigratio...
- Stuck without a proposed course of action
- Ready-made right-wing talking points
- How natural is masturbation?
- "I Just Remembered Chris Matthews Was White"
- Joke of the day
- Feingold feels the heat
- The Postal Service - Such Great Heights
- Quote of the day
- The economy recovers
- Fundamentalists and the atheists who love them
- True Financial Injustice
- Rainy mood
- What kind of idiot would build a pyramid next to a...
- Undeep thought
- How big is Australia?
- What works best in online dating photos?
- Twitter funnies
- Inertia's such a bitch
- Scott Brown is pivotal
- Scott Brown's victory speech
- The return of Northeastern Republicans
- Build your own health care decision tree
- CHART 1 + CHART 2 = CHART 3
- Next on the Democrats' Senate worry list
- Too close to call
- Quote of the day
- Google.cn uncensors itself: Chinese hustle for max...
- The case for Coakley
- Avatar had a deleted sex scene
- Scott Brown wants hospitals to turn away all rape ...
- The new marijuana majority
- Scott Brown for Senate
- Patenting a sarcasm punctuation mark
- Photo of the day
- Good news guys
- "Twenty words you can't say in Alabama"
- "I just want my normal gay son back."
- Lest we forget how awesome Conan actually is...
- Five reasons why libertarians shouldn't hate gover...
- Bad framing on the excise tax
- What in tarnation?!
- Quote of the day
- Dawkins back at his best
- Four funky GOP primaries
- Quote of the day
- Douthat on the fillibuster
- The U.S.'s largest trading partner
- Ignoring the cost of torture
- Quote of the day
- Capitalism, market economy slowly take root in N. ...
- Dept. of long shots
- And the beat goes on
- Ave Imperator! Silenti te salutant!
-
▼
January
(57)
No comments:
Post a Comment